Personally I’m disgusted. It will be interesting to see if there is any call for something vaguely approaching civility from the right — like how far can you go, really? Do you just shout louder and louder and look more and more like an ass. Will they moon him the next time he talks? I remember being told during the last decade that you don’t have to respect the man, but you should respect the office. Now I wonder what that is supposed to mean?
The author of the paragraphs below has been, in my opinion, a tepid, try-to-please-as-many-as-you-can, centrist journalist who has drifted somewhat to the right under the prevailing winds of the last decade. — rls
http://voices.washingtonpost.com/postpartisan/2009/09/racisim_in_the_house_chamber.html#more
Some of the same ugly feeling was present in the House chamber Wednesday night. The lack of respect shown the president of the United States was both appalling and shocking. Rep. Joe Wilson (R-S.C.) yelled “You lie,” when Obama said that his health care proposal would not cover illegal aliens. Other Republicans held up placards saying “What Plan?” or “What Bill?” as Obama was speaking. The Party of Rudeness had outdone itself.
All presidents get vilified. It’s part of the job. White House aide Van Jones stepped down last week amid controversy over the fact that, among other things, he once signed a petition declaring that the administration of George W. Bush “may indeed have deliberately allowed 9/11 to happen, perhaps as a pretext for war.” Bill Clinton was accused of running drugs through Arkansas’s obscure Mena Airport, among many, many other things.
But when the fringe starts pushing into the center, then attention must be paid. In general, the Republicans in the House treated Obama disrespectfully, and some of them treated him with contempt. When opposition to a piece of legislation turns swiftly into disdain for the man — when policy becomes personal — a columnist is permitted to wonder why. He is permitted, furthermore, to wonder if some of Obama’s more hateful critics are not expressing a repressed bigotry — the feeling that the man up on the dais cannot really be the president of the United States. After all, he does not look like one.
It would be an awful thing if genuine criticism was labeled racist and therefore muffled. But the disrespect shown Obama seems so disproportionate to the issue — health-care reform — that I just have to wonder. Wilson later apologized for his outburst, but he cannot take it back. It was, as has been said of another incident, a teachable moment. I hope he and other Republicans learn from it.
